Sleeping in the Ground

Sleeping in the Ground

Book - 2017
Average Rating:
Rate this:
Following a massacre at a Yorkshire church, Detective Superintendent Alan Banks and his team are challenged to unravel a mystery involving a killer who is hiding in plain sight.
Publisher: [Toronto] : McClelland & Stewart, 2017.
ISBN: 9780771072703
Branch Call Number: FIC Robin
Characteristics: 374 p. ; 24 cm.


From Library Staff

tomato Feb 09, 2018

I thought this was an excellent book. Banks ain't retired yet! Love the interplay of the characters, and I'm even used to the music and food specifications now - they used to annoy me until I realized that they're giving us brief insights into Banks' life, past and present. Peter Robinson hasn... Read More »

From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment

Jul 20, 2018

I unfortunately have to agree with a lot of these reviews. The author went into far too great detail about music and food. There was a lot of filler and I found myself skimming through to get back to the point. Also, the angst Banks felt over both Emily and Jenny didn't go anywhere. An average read.

May 19, 2018

I really like this series but this was not a good book. There were three story lines that added a considerable amount of filler. First Banks attended a funeral for his first love and that story went on and on through the entire book. As well Jenny Fuller returned, another lost love. Then there was the weather. As in previous books the rain and flooding in Eastvale played a part in the story. Then there was the excessive amount of music references that have expanded from Classical to include Jazz and Rock plus there is now poetry as well. Finally there was the mass shooting, the hunt and conclusion. Without all the added stuff this story would probably be a novelette. An average novelette.

tomato Feb 09, 2018

I thought this was an excellent book. Banks ain't retired yet! Love the interplay of the characters, and I'm even used to the music and food specifications now - they used to annoy me until I realized that they're giving us brief insights into Banks' life, past and present. Peter Robinson hasn't lost his touch.

Jan 15, 2018

A real disappointment from a generally very good author. As many have commented, too much filler and not so much content, making for a tiresome read. The whole scenario was very reminiscent of a book by another British author (woman writer with widowed doctor and detective brother as protagonists?) with only slight differences. Supt. Banks is becoming too PC and flawless........he needs some human characteristics and foibles, and indeed, the rest of the characters seem to be heading this way also.

I had looked forward to reading this so much that I feel that I have been really let down by Peter Robinson. Perhaps you can't hit home runs all the time but this is a definite strike out.

Dec 22, 2017

Interesting how Robinson draws on current events and puts them into his novel. This novel is set during the rainy season in the midlands that resulted in much flooding. The novel certainly captures the reader's attention with the shooting of the wedding party as they leave the church. Robinson later has his characters refer to it as the "Red Wedding" which reminded me of such a scene in one of the episodes of "Game of Thrones". Robinson throws too much filler into this book that I was not interested in reading about - many comments about songs/singers/musical pieces, much drinking in pubs with friends or having drinks in their homes with every drink named, many dinners out with friends in which the menu is extensively described, reflections on certain lines in poems that offer insight into past events in Banks' life, and then the long story about his first love as a teen and its consequences. In between these ramblings, Robinson does have his police team slowly making some headway in identifying the murderer and finally, just a few pages from the end, the story comes to a dramatic conclusion. I skipped many paragraphs and pages to follow the plot, so a quick read, but not one that was totally satisfying.

Dec 21, 2017

The opening of this book is gruesome; if you aren't turned away by that, then it does become an enjoyable read. I liked how it wrapped up.

Nov 22, 2017

I thought this was another fine book in the Inspector Banks series. How it compares with previous books is less important to me than whether it was entertaining when I read it. And it is very entertaining due to the strong characters Peter Robinson has created and the story lines of all the books in the series. I look forward to more of them.

Nov 21, 2017

Very pedestrian. Way too many musical references (do we need to know every song and album Banks plays) and too many food references (just tell us he had dinner - we don't need to know the whole menu). Like many older authors, Peter Robinson appears to be headed for the end of this series and this will likely be my last go at an Inspector Banks book. (technically now Detective Superintendent) Sorry to say that I found it to be exceedingly boring.

Nov 09, 2017

I like Banks and agree this book is rather disappointing. Too much irrelevant details so I can afford flying over pages w/o missing any important info.

Oct 16, 2017

As a fan of this author, I am quite disappointed. It seems to be pretty common for long-term series writers for the quality to decline as time goes on. This book has Robinson's usual great atmospheric writing and sense of place, but the plot is outlandish and the characters, including the murderer, stiff and not believable. I also did not welcome the reappearance of the long-gone Jenny Fuller, the dipshit "profiler," as a possible love interest for Banks, even though we are reassured by one of the characters that she is still "a bit of all right," i.e., good enough for the aging Banks to find sexually attractive. Robinson is just getting desperate to keep this series going. He also approaches self-parody with the extensive laundry lists of what Banks eats, drinks and listens to. This has long been a Robinson trademark, but in this book we are treated to a listing of the entire dinner menu; just ridiculous.

Having said all that, even a bad book by Robinson is better than other books by most writers. Fans will still want to read this book, but I would hate for it to be the first book read by someone new to his work.

View All Comments

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Subject Headings


Find it at OPL

To Top